Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Evaluating Perspectives on Personality.

Psychoanalytic, Social-cognitive, Humanistic, and Traits are four perspectives on personlity. Of these, I believe that the one which makes the most sense is the Social-cognitive approach, although it does have its shortcomings, admittedly.
The Psychoanalytic approach is one that assumes human behaviour and personality as guided by conflicts between the unconscious elements within our being. Motives for all kinds of behaviour are often unconscious. This does not really hold true, as we are actually aware of our own motives when we do things. The trio of psychic stances suggested by the psychoanalytic theory are not necessarily always applicable and hence may not always affect the behaviour of an individual.
The Social-cognitive approach to personality sees personality as being moulded by factors around them. This is, in my opinion, as good a viewpoint as it gets. What it means is that an individual's personality differs from another who is in a totally different environment. What we end up with is what we have today: uniquely different individuals with small similarities in personalities with other indiviuals from the same environments. Differences in individuals can be attributed to environment; things such as music, friends, family, school and religion, to name a few, can shape the direction of someone's personality. For example, someone who is in a quarrelsome family would probably tend to get agitated easily. Conversely, an individual from a caring and accommodating family might have the same personality. These two individuals would then differ in this aspect of their personalities because of a different family environment. How this works is simple. In any environment, individuals experience things which evoke different responses, and these responses, when made frequent, become a part of that individual's personality.
However the Social-cognitive approach does not factor in the unseen aspects of any individual's reactions or responses to events. These include his/her emotions, motives and so on. Inward traits like these often are not expressed, and not affected by environment as much as outward responses. For example, how a person feels towards something/someone may not change, even though everyone feels differently. This is simply because the emotion is unexpressed, and thereby not frowned upon or disapproved. In such a way, the emotion may not be subject to change. However a counterargument for this is that the emotion does actually manifest itself in the person's actions, and hence inwards traits will also be influenced. True, but perhaps not every individual is prone to revealing their emotions, and some are more adept at masking their feelings than others, so I will leave it at that.
The Humanistic approach believes that behaviour is affected by the needs of a person. However, the approach bandies about many vague terms without much elaboration or explanation, and does not take into account and account for negative or "bad" personalities. The Traits approach classifies human behaviour and personalities according to certain traits that each individual exhibits. By itself, it is actually an accurate representation. But to begin with, these traits can be moulded be environment, and hence, a person's personality can be moulded too. The Traits approach is reliable and accurate, but it should probably fall in as a sub-category of the Social-cognitive approach, because all the traits that appear in the Traits approach can be moulded and shaped and changed, according to the Social-cognitive approach.
I believe that the four theories raised are good, logical efforts to account for human personalities, but, many of them fall short in terms of sound reasoning. The Social-cognitive approach, coupled with the Traits approach, is probably the best aproach, in my opinion, as it covers all ground, leaving very few loopholes in reasoning, and is the easiest theory to apply to real-life at a glance.

No comments:

Post a Comment